Methodology · version 0.3

How we rank

Every score comes from information organizations already file with the IRS. The formula below is the same for every organization. No one can pay to be ranked, to rank higher, or to change a score.

The America's Best Score (0–100)

MeasurePointsHow it's calculated
Operating reserves25Net assets ÷ monthly expenses, latest year. Full points at 36 months or more, scaled down to zero. Ceiling: when cash and savings alone exceed 36 months of expenses, these points fade out, reaching zero at 120 months (10 years). Land, buildings and invested endowments don't count toward the ceiling.
Financial balance20Surplus or deficit in each filed year, scored separately and averaged. A year at +5% or better earns full points, −10% or worse earns none. Averaging every year means one strong year can't make up for weak ones. Ceiling: a year that keeps more than 50% of its spending as surplus starts losing points, and a surplus of 150% or more earns none that year. One big capital-campaign year costs little; years in a row of not spending what comes in costs a lot.
Transparency20Up to 15 points for 3 consecutive years of full Form 990 filings, plus 5 when the latest filing is within 2 years.
Program growth15Annual growth in total expenses, a measure of how much work the organization is delivering. Full points at +15% a year, zero at −15%.
Track record10Years since IRS tax-exempt recognition. Full points at 25 years.
Debt load10Liabilities ÷ total assets. Full points at 10% or less, zero at 60% or more.

Who gets ranked

  • Organizations with at least 2 years of full Form 990 filings. Smaller filers (990-EZ and 990-N) are listed but not ranked yet.
  • Ranked: a score of 60 or more.
  • America's Best: a score of 85 or more and in the top 5% of ranked organizations in the same cause nationally, and at least 65% of total spending on programs in its latest Form 990 (Part IX). When a return doesn't report a usable split, the organization isn't held back by the missing figure. It's renewed every year, so the designation stays rare and means something. See this year's winners, or what sets them apart.
  • Ties: scores are shown as whole numbers, so many organizations can share a score, including 100. Within a city, organizations with the same score are ordered by, in turn, a larger share of spending on programs, more years of full Form 990 filings, and larger total revenue.
  • City rank badges ("#1 of 7 in Houston") appear only where at least 5 organizations are ranked in that city and cause.
  • Organizations that exist mainly to fund others aren't ranked with service providers. That covers private foundations, supporting organizations the IRS classifies under section 509(a)(3) (such as "Foundation for…" and endowment funds of a single charity), and any organization whose contributions and program revenue are under 50% of its revenue. They're listed with the reason.
  • A city ranking is indexed by search engines once at least 3 organizations qualify.
  • Everyone we review appears on the page. Organizations that aren't ranked are shown with the reason.
  • We rely on the IRS's classification of each organization. When it's clearly wrong for this directory (for example, an organization of another faith coded as a Christian church), we leave that organization out. Tell us if you see one.

Why we score this way

America's Best is meant to recognize organizations that are both financially sound and putting their resources to work for their mission. Our principles:

  • Stability matters. Reserves, steady small surpluses, low debt and years of on-time filings let an organization keep its promises through a bad year. Most of the score rewards them.
  • Money held back isn't excellence. Without limits, an organization that raised money and spent almost none of it would max out reserves and balance. So reserves and surpluses earn points up to a healthy level and then fade out. Ten or more years of cash on hand, or keeping most of what comes in year after year, earns nothing on those measures.
  • Programs come first, but overhead isn't the enemy. We don't give points for low overhead. Good organizations need staff, systems and fundraising, and scoring overhead pushes charities to underinvest in them. We do require that an America's Best winner spends at least 65% of its budget on programs. That's the BBB Wise Giving Alliance's long-standing standard, and most nonprofits clear it easily.
  • Lines come from the data, checked against outside standards. Each limit is set where the national Form 990 data and a published standard agree. The cash ceiling starts at 3 years, the BBB Wise Giving Alliance's line for accumulating too much, and only about 6 in 100 scored nonprofits hold more cash than that. The program line of 65% sits at or below the 25th percentile in every cause and every size group, so no kind of organization is singled out. See the benchmarks.
  • Missing data never counts against anyone. If a return doesn't report cash or a program/overhead split, that check is skipped rather than scored as a failure.
  • Land, buildings and endowments aren't hoarding. A land trust's conserved land or a museum's building is part of its mission, so the cash ceiling looks only at cash and savings.
  • One formula for everyone. Every organization in every cause and state is scored the same way, and the formula is published here.

Independence

America's Best Churches is published by 3nity, which also provides websites, fundraising and marketing services to nonprofits. Our rules:

  • Being a 3nity client never affects a score or rank. Clients are labeled on their profiles.
  • Claiming a profile, taking the free assessment, or appearing on The Nonprofit Platform podcast never changes a score.
  • Profile details an organization adds (logo, mission, programs) are shown as provided by the organization.

Data sources and freshness

IRS Exempt Organizations Business Master File and electronically filed Form 990 returns. Scores are recalculated whenever a new filing arrives. Form 990 data typically lags 12–24 months behind an organization's fiscal year.

Found an error?

If your organization's information is wrong or out of date, claim your profile to correct it.
Claim your profileReport an error

Common questions

What is the America's Best Score?

A 0–100 score built from the IRS Form 990 filings churches already make. It adds six measures: operating reserves (25 points), financial balance (20), program growth (15), transparency (20), track record (10) and debt load (10). The same formula applies to everyone.

Who gets ranked?

Organizations with at least 2 years of full Form 990 filings and a score of 60 or more. Private foundations, supporting organizations and other groups that mainly fund others are listed but not ranked with service providers.

What does America's Best mean?

A score of 85 or more and a place in the top 5% of ranked organizations in the same cause nationally. The designation is renewed every year.

Doesn't more money in the bank always mean a stronger organization?

Up to a point. Reserves earn full points at 36 months of expenses. But when cash and savings exceed 36 months, the reserves points start to fade, and they're gone at 10 years. Very large surpluses year after year fade the same way. Money held far beyond what an organization needs isn't serving its mission yet. Land, buildings and invested endowments don't count toward this limit.

Do you penalize overhead?

No points are given or taken for overhead, because good organizations need staff, systems and fundraising. The one requirement is that an America's Best winner spends at least 65% of its total budget on programs, the BBB Wise Giving Alliance's standard. Most nonprofits clear it; see the benchmarks page for typical figures by cause and state.

How are ties broken?

Scores are whole numbers, so organizations can share a score. Within a city, ties are ordered by a larger share of spending on programs, then more years of full Form 990 filings, then larger total revenue. Organizations whose returns don't report the program split come after those that do among equal scores.

Can an organization pay to be ranked or to rank higher?

No. No one can pay to be ranked, to rank higher, or to change a score. Claiming a profile is free and never changes a score. America's Best Churches is published by 3nity; its clients get no special treatment and are labeled.

Where does the data come from?

The IRS Exempt Organizations Business Master File and electronically filed Form 990 returns. Filings usually lag an organization's fiscal year by 12 to 24 months, and scores update as new filings arrive.